Blue Half Circle
Yellow Star
Blue Half Circle Right
Left Half Circle
Yellow Half Circle
Blue Half Circle
Yellow Stars


By on

Read Time: 3 minutes

Hallelujah! Children in Virginia can now play outside without their parents getting investigated for neglect.

Sunday night, Gov. Glenn Youngkin signed what is colloquially called the “Reasonable Childhood Independence” bill, after it passed both houses unanimously. (Democrats and Republicans AGREED on a PARENTING issue in Virginia? YES.)

The bill narrows the state’s neglect laws, which had been so vague and broad that parents were getting investigated simply for letting their kids walk or play outside.

Elsa Hackel, 12, testifies in favor of Virginia’s “Reasonable Childhood Independence” bill.

“The cops were at the door before I got my coat off.”

The new law affirms that neglect is when you put a child in serious and obvious danger – not simply anytime you take your eyes off them, or anytime a disapproving neighbor or official can dream up a far-fetched peril.

This is great news for people like Elsa Hackel, 12. She testified to the legislature about the time she was walking home from the bus stop in Falls Church, VA., at age 9. Four police officers showed up at her door “before I could get my coat off!” she told the legislators. “They said they got a call about a kid alone in the cold seen going into this house.”

Elsa was terrified her parents would be taken away. “Since then,” she said, “I haven’t wanted to go outside very often.”

Her mother, naval architect Evelyn Hackel, testified, “I never imagined there would be more police involved for that then for when my neighbor was assaulted by a fugitive.”

“You must be outside if your kids are outside.”

Emily Fields was visited by Child Protective Services for letting her kids play in the front yard.

Anna Fields from rural Pearisburg, VA., testified, too. She’s 9. About a year ago, she said, “My brother, sister, and I were all playing outside and a neighbor said we weren’t safe because we didn’t have any grown-ups around.”

The siblings were playing next door to their own home, Anna’s mom, Emily Fields, testified. But thanks to that neighbor’s call, “Child Protective Services showed up at our door. We were accused of neglect for letting the children play in the front yard. I was told that I personally have to be visible to my neighbors so that they know that my children are supervised.”

An amazingly broad coalition.

The bill, sponsored by Sen. Jill Vogel (R., District 27, Warrenton), with chief co-patron Sen. Jennifer Boysko (D., District 33, Herndon), and co-sponsor Jennifer McLellan (D. 9., Richmond), changes that. It was supported by experts across the political spectrum, from parents’ rights and conservative women’s groups, to anti-poverty and racial justice advocates.

These included Will Estrada, President of the Parental Rights Foundation, and Valerie L’Herrou from the Virginia Poverty Law Center, with leadership by Debra Rodman, a former Democratic member of the Virginia House of delegates. Other supporters included Families Forward, ALEC Action, the Independent Women’s Forum, and the Legal Aid Justice Center. Your friends here at Let Grow helped coordinate these efforts.

Sen. Jill Vogel, sponsor of the bill, testifies. Behind her, in print dress, is Debra Rodman.

The sponsors testified that the bill will let Virginia parents breathe easier, especially families in minority communities, who have a higher rate of Child Protective Services investigations.

Sen. Vogel told her fellow legislators that this law saves precious resources by allowing Child Protective Services to focus on children in true danger, and it also saves families from “investigations that are unnecessarily traumatic or disruptive.”

Virginia becomes the fifth state to pass such a law, following Utah, Oklahoma, Texas and Colorado.

“We need to stop believing that whenever parents allow their children out of their sight, they are endangering them. This is a family rights and human rights issue whose time has come,” said Diane Redleaf, a long time child and family advocate and Let Grow’s legal consultant.

Comments are closed for this article.