Chicago mom fighting back
When 10 -year-old Braylin Harvey was picked up seven minutes late from his Chicago public school, the school called the Department of Child and Family Services to report a case of neglect.
Two days later Braylin was pulled out of class and interrogated by a caseworker. The next day a caseworker showed up at his home to investigate his mom, JaNay Dodson, herself a Chicago Public School teacher for 19 years.
Now the mom is fighting back. “I’m getting it out there to make people aware,” said Dodson. While she is certain she will be found not guilty of neglect, she was stunned by how easy it was to open an investigation.
Kids had just returned after a year of remote learning
The day this all began – Tuesday, March 2 — was just the second day Chicago public school students were back at their desks in a year. The bus schedule at Inter-American, Braylin’s school, was confusing and when Dodson realized her son wasn’t going to be getting a bus ride home and that she wouldn’t be able to pick him up in time, either – because she’d be teaching — she started calling the school to alert them. She couldn’t get through to a human. Meantime, she called her brother to go pick up her son, and he arrived at 4:37.
School dismisses at 4 p.m. There is a 30-minute grace period after which, according to Chicago Public School policy, the school must alert the police and child protective services.
The school’s principal, Daniela Bylaitis, did not return my call. But in an email obtained by the website Block Club Chicago, she wrote to Dodson that:
“Yesterday, Braylin was not picked up from school until 4:37 p.m. I am empathetic to the challenges of balancing work and family responsibilities, however, all school employees are mandated reporters and are required to follow CPS protocols and guidance. Please be sure that Braylin is picked up on time tomorrow.”
And yet, the policy also states that if the school sees no one is picking up a child, it school should try to reach the parent or emergency contacts, which did not happen.
“Picking up a child late is not child neglect.”
That Thursday, two days after the incident, Dodson went to pick up her son and waited around to see if anyone else got picked up late. Indeed, a child was picked up at 4:47. “When his father pulled up, I asked him if he had ever been late before and he told me this was the third time he was late this week because something’s going on with the scheduling of the school buses. And I told him what had happened and he said, ‘What? No one has said that to me.’”
Dodson’s son has been at the school since kindergarten and she, too, had never experienced anything like this.
So she went to the Local School Council the next night to discuss the incident. Some of the members drafted a letter to the head of Chicago Public Schools, Janice Jackson, asking her to end the draconian pick-up policy. “We do not think it is reasonable to equate being late for pickup, in isolation, with child neglect,” they wrote.
Since all teachers are already mandated reporters – that is, they are required to alert the authorities anytime they believe a child is being maltreated – the school is already looking out for neglected kids, they noted, making the pick-up policy “not only redundant but purposefully and unreasonably hurtful.”
Then too, the letter pointed out, it’s not like this has been a normal school year. Context matters.
A child protective services investigation is traumatic no matter what the outcome
And finally: anytime child protective services gets involved in a family’s life, it is traumatic for the kids and the adults.
“He was scared,” says Dodson of her son. After convincing him that no one was going to take him away, “I had to sit him down and explain, ‘I’m not fighting for you. I’m fighting for every other parent who cannot,’” Dodson said.
That’s a lot of other parents. Dodson has already heard from a mom in Texas who said her school employs the same over-the-top protocol. And in DC, the public school handbook says that if a child is not picked up after school dismissal at 3:15:
School staff will call the parent/guardian after dismissal to request immediate pick up from school (at 3:30). If the student is not picked up within 30 minutes, a second call will be made to the parent/guardian and emergency contacts on the student’s afterschool enrollment form (at 4:00). If a student is not picked up within an hour of the first call, CFSA will be contacted and asked to take custody of the student (at 4:30).
From normal kid to ward of the state in 75 minutes.
Which is not to say it’s easy for schools to deal with a child no one picks up. Dodson herself believes it makes more sense to call the cops, so they can watch the child until the parent arrives. But opening a case of neglect makes sense only if the kid is repeatedly stranded. Being seven minutes late one time is not neglect or abuse.
No, abuse is when you call child protective services for the moral equivalent of a hangnail.